Every new year, homeowners from all over Citra call upon roofing contractors for repairs. In some cases, many are seeking guidance on having a new roof or tearing down and replacing their existing roof. The question we often receive: metal roof VS shingles for roofs?

In fact, we receive variations such as “metal roof VS shingles in cold climate?” or “metal roof VS shingles resale value?”

In this article, we aim to answer these questions in depth to help our valued Citra homeowners make the right decision for their property.

Metal Roof and Shingle Complete Comparison Sheet

  1. Metal Roof Features (4 Items)
  2. Roofing Shingles Features (4 Items)
  3. Economical Choice
  4. Long-Term Investment
  5. Which One to Choose?

Metal Roof Vs Shingles for Roofs

Metal Roofs


When it comes to metal roofs VS shingles, metal roofs have two varieties and several materials to choose from.

Corrugated roofs were common in Citra homes during the 80s and 90s. It is a corrugated metal sheet covering a full square of a roof. Its shape allows it to deliver rainwater and rid rooftop debris straight into the gutter system.

Standing seam metal roofs are modern variants of corrugated metal roofing. Instead of single metal sheet squares, a dense metal bar covers the slope of residential property roofs. Its density provides improved  durability, longevity, and insulation for properties.

In addition, metal roofs have four material variants:

  • Galvanized roof: A steel roof with a zinc coat to improve its lifespan and durability
  • Galvalumed roof: Instead of zinc, these roofs have an aluminum coat
  • Aluminum: The most expensive, lightweight, and rust-proof residential roofing material. Has commercial variants too.
standing seam metal roofs with hailstorm dent

If you want long-term protection and extremely durable roofs, standing seam metal roofs are definitely your best choice. They can even withstand extreme hailstorms such as the one pictured here.


If you intend replacing your shingle roof with a metal roof, you’re looking at high costs in addition to roofing tear-off labor.

Corrugated steel metal roofs cost about $5-$6 per square feet. On the other hand, standing seam metal roofing costs about $11-$15 per square feet. These figures have yet to include installation labor costs and roofing material variant costs (aluminum is the most expensive of the three). However, if you can do DIY metal roof installations, your cost will definitely be lower than average as a result.

However, when it comes to metal roof VS shingles resale value, you’re better off with the high property value a standing seam metal roof provides properties.

Durability and Longevity

In the case of metal roof vs shingles for roofs, the latter has a long lifespan with extended durability.

Corrugated galvanized and galvalumed steel have an estimated 50-plus years of lifespan and protection. On the other hand, its aluminum variant can last for 70-plus years with regular maintenance.

Standing seam galvanized and galvalumed steel have a lifespan of 70 years and further with effective maintenance. Furthermore, its aluminum variants can outgrow their homeowner’s lifespans while providing top-quality durability and protection.

Value for Money

Regardless whether is a metal roof cooler than shingles or not, metal roofs have excellent value for money. It provides long-term durability and aesthetics. Furthermore, elastomeric paint coats allow them to have added rust-proofing and weathering protection.

True enough, if you can spend a bit more for your roof, go for metal roofs.

Roofing Shingles


Two types of asphalt roofing shingles exist. These are standard asphalt shingles and architectural asphalt shingles.

Asphalt shingles are the regular roofing material almost every American homeowner uses. It comes in different colors. They usually come in three-tabs, which earned them the name “three tab shingles.” Manufacturers create them using asphalt and a felt underlayment for waterproofing.

Architectural shingles are the premium varieties. They have excellent curb appeal. In fact, remodelers use them extensively in reviving old properties. They come in laminated varieties but are always manufactured with added density and durability than asphalt shingles.

contractor installing a new asphalt shingle roof

Regular asphalt shingle roofs are affordable and offer adequate protection for all properties.


When it comes to metal roof VS shingles for roofing, asphalt roofing wins for homeowners with smaller budgets.

It only costs $4-$5 to purchase an asphalt shingle bundle. This translates to spending $1-$2 for a square foot of roof.

If you have extra money to spend on better roofs, you can choose architectural shingles. However, you’ll be spending $6-$8 per square foot. True enough, the price jump is quite high but so are the benefits homeowners will receive.

Durability and Longevity

When it comes to metal roofs vs shingles for roofs, it loses out when it comes to durability and longevity. However, that is not to say asphalt shingles cannot provide adequate roofing protection and lifespan.

A standard asphalt shingle roof has a 15-30 year lifespan on average. Furthermore, it can withstand one to two hailstorms before it requires replacement.

On the other hand, architectural shingle roofs can last 30-40 years with effective maintenance. Its high-durability material extends its lifespan. However, it can only withstand one to two hailstorms as well.

Related: How to Check Your Roof Properly After a Hailstorm

Value for Money

True enough, if you need emergency roofing replacement, going with standard asphalt shingle roofs is a good choice. Furthermore, architectural shingles are excellent choices to increase the value of your property.

Architectural shingle manufacturers offer their products with a wide range of colors, patterns, and other appeal-increasing features. While it will drive their prices higher, you gain high property value in the process too.

beautiful architectural shingle roofs

Architectural shingles offer excellent durability and curb appeal despite its high price.

Economical Choice: Roofing Shingles

As we mentioned earlier, roofing shingles are excellent if you need a new roof on a tight budget. Standard asphalt shingles won’t dent your budget too badly yet provide adequate protection for your roof. Unfortunately, many homes use them.

Therefore, if you want to stand out, having architectural shingle roofs is a better yet more costly option. However, the extended lifespan, durability, and improved curb appeal are definitely something you shouldn’t pass up having.

Related: The Most Accurate Asphalt Shingle Roof Price Calculator

Long-Term Investment: Metal Roofs

If you’ve been planning your new or replacement roof for quite some time, then consider having metal roofs — standing seam metal ones in particular.

With a long-term durability that provides the highest standard of protection consistently, you can never go wrong with metal roofs.

Which One to Choose?

As experienced and knowledgeable contractors, we understand that any new or replacement roofs are huge financial commitments. Therefore, finding a contractor that works with your budget and helps you cut down costs are essential in any roof installation or replacement project.

We can help you find the right asphalt shingles or metal roof suppliers you need. In addition, we can find the ideal materials and execute the best roofing installation or replacement for your property. Contact Kilburn Construction Company to help you with your roofing needs today!